Is Jamal Lewis a shakey pick?

[scribbles24]

Man, 2 years ago, this guy was the top RB behind Marshall Faulk near the end of the season.
think he knee surgery ended this top draft pick for fantasy?

who would be the top 5 backs on draft day in your opiniion?

[Marc]

I would say:

1. Faulk
2. A. Green
3. R. Williams
4. George
5. Holmes

Lewis isn't even ranked: http://www.komments.com/articles/cs.shtml#rb

[dwfresh]

I had Ricky Willimas and Eddie George last year last year and they weren't so hot. I won't put them in the top 5. I'd put Shaun ALexander and whoever the Broncos decide to use instaed.

[Marc]

Williams and George, I think, will be top five RBs -- George especially. He was banged up all last year and is back this year totally healthy. He was an MVP-type guy two years ago and he should regain that form. As for Williams, he will be the focus of the Dolphins offense and they are better than the Saints so he should give you pretty good production if he stays healty. Sometimes, a change in scenery is all a guy needs.