By Gary
Cozine
Saturday, November 3rd, 2001
America loves an underdog. It's the reason we like Bill Murray. The sentiment
can be seen in movies like The Rainmaker, A Civil Action, and
The Insider where the little guy takes down big business. This is
a vital form of escapism because 99% of this country - to say nothing of
the world - identifies with the underdog and the sheer thrill of watching
the small fry topple the huge corporation is irresistible.
There is solid historical reasoning for this. After all, this country was
founded by men and women who broke away from an empire that, at the time,
controlled a good portion of the world. But our affection for the little
guy even predates the 18th century - it is at least as old as David and Goliath.
It's hard to believe a team that won the second most games in the National
League this year, has a player in Luis Gonzales who put up legitimate triple
crown numbers (that is. if you forget about a guy in San Francisco named
Barry), has the best 1-2 punch of starting pitchers of any team in a very,
very long time, and who got off to a 2-0 start in the World Series could
still be considered an underdog - but that's exactly what the Arizona
Diamondbacks are.
Even taking all of the above into consideration, Arizona still have a lot
going against them - this is only their fourth year of existence in MLB;
they are being lead by a rookie manager who's job last year was to comb his
sparse hair, put on a suit and tie, and talk into a microphone; they have
$28 million less to play with than the Yankees, and for all the experience
on the team roster (7 of the players are older than 35), only one has a World
Series ring - Craig Counsell, when he was with the Florida Marlins (another
underdog team).
Compare all of that to an opponent that has been to the World Series 38 times,
whose shortstop is 27-years-old and already has four World Series rings (some
players - Tony Gwynn, and (thus far) Barry Bonds, just to name a couple -
play their entire careers without ever getting their fingers sized), has
been to the postseason the past seven years running, whose current players
have 58 World Series titles collectively and have had, at one time or another,
players on their roster with names like Ruth, DiMaggio, Mantle, and Gehrig
and you begin to understand that the Diamondbacks aren't playing the Yankees,
they're playing Goliath.
Arizona and New York illustrate a paradox that is inherent in another American
institution - Capitalism. The free market rewards companies that are ruthless
on their competition and seize control of the market.
Microsoft is now a very large company run by a geek. But it was once a very
small company run by a geek. At one time, IBM was Big Money and Microsoft
was Loose Change. As Microsoft gained influence and forced out smaller rivals,
its stock price soared which infused additional capital into the company
coffers, providing powerful leverage. Eventually, this lead to Microsoft
toppling IBM. What is ironic is that at that point the government stepped
in and instead of rewarding the company for achieving its mandate, it declared
it a monopoly and punished it by threatening to break it up.
Once a company or a team ceases to be an underdog, it falls out of our favors.
It becomes Goliath and we start searching the horizon for a new David to defeat
it. I'm not suggesting that we break the Yankees up and distribute the players
among lesser-known teams like the Devil Rays, but I think salary caps are
in order for baseball. Smarter people than myself have pointed out that
professional sports is one of the few businesses in the world where the quality
of the game is dependent upon evenly matched teams. If the Yankees were to
destroy every team they played, every time they played them, eventually people
(including Yankee fans) would become bored and stop attending games. Revenues
would dry up, and the integrity of the game itself would be jeopardized.
This year the Yankees have made it difficult to root against them without
feeling like a traitor to the nation - they have traded in their Yankee caps
(symbols of baseball hegemony) for NYPD and NYFD hats (symbols of martyred
heroes) and are from a city that has been the locus of our grieving universe
for the past six weeks. You have to remind yourself that you are not cheering
for the defeat of New York City and its people, but rather for the overthrow
of Goliath.
Back
to MLB
Back to
Home