Sports Central Message Boards

Sports Central Message Boards (https://www.sports-central.org/community/boards/index.php)
-   National Football League (https://www.sports-central.org/community/boards/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Instant Reply, Upon Further Review (https://www.sports-central.org/community/boards/showthread.php?t=3016)

Marc 01-21-2002 10:54 PM

Instant Reply, Upon Further Review
 
With all the controversy still surrounding the Pats/Raiders game on Saturday night, Craig Hardesty brings up another issue: instant replay. He basically says mistakes are inevitable and NFL refs are good and we should just play the game without dealing with replays. Raiders fans definitely aren't on instant replay's side... as instant replay was the reason their call was overturned, costing them their season. What's your take?
Quote:

Instant Reply, Upon Further Review

https://www.sports-central.org/sport...cle111_2.shtml

By Craig Hardesty
Monday, January 21st, 2002

You can bet your last challenge that every member of the Oakland Raiders will be replaying Tom Brady's infamous "non-fumble" over and over again in their minds for the entire offseason. And it is an even safer bet that every member of the Raiders also wishes that the officials had not replayed the non-fumble at all this past Saturday night.

Even if you can stomach the shaky explanation of that pivotal play (the referee ruled that Brady's arm motion constituted an incomplete pass even though he was clearly holding the ball when Charles Woodson slapped it out of his hand), what is a lot harder to accept is the fact that the original ruling was overturned because of instant replay.

To make matters worse, Patriots head coach Bill Belichick did not even challenge the call himself - the play was reviewed automatically because of a very suspect "under two minutes" rule. According to NFL instant replay law, any close call that occurs during the last two minutes of the half will automatically be reviewed.

What about the other 56 minutes of the game? Don't close calls happen during that time, as well?

bama4256 01-21-2002 11:07 PM

I'm for the instant replay. Officials are human and the replay should only help and not hinder. The replay must show overwhelming evidence to overturn a call. If's its real real close let the call stand.

bostonsportsfan 01-21-2002 11:20 PM

He brings up a very interesting point, but either way, I really don't think anyone will ever be fully satisfied with it.

I happen to like Instant Replay, but the system is flawed in some respects. Without it, the referee can obviously miss a call or commit some type of error. They're only human after all.

Dre2g 01-21-2002 11:39 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by bama4256
I'm for the instant replay. Officials are human and the replay should only help and not hinder. The replay must show overwhelming evidence to overturn a call. If's its real real close let the call stand.
I could not have said it any better.

Anthony 01-24-2002 04:02 AM

If you have instant replay at all, it must be used in all situations where a call can be disputed. This business of pass interference not being reviewable is ridiculous. It's like finding a cure for cancer and then passing a law banning cancer patients from obtaining it! Another thing I would like to see changed is what happens when a challenge does not result in the call being overturned; instead of deducting a time-out, I say penalize the team five yards for delay of game - the challenge did end up delaying the game, did it not?

And if they can't bring themselves to include pass interference as a reviewable play, they should institute a 15-yard penalty (plus an automatic first down, of course) for "non-flagrant" pass interference - or at the very least limit the penalty to half the distance to the goal in the case of interference on a very long pass. And a safeguard could be put in place to prevent deliberate fouls at the very end of a half or game, and that would be that the clock would be reset to how much time remained prior to the snap on any play where pass interference was committed in the last two minutes of a half or game (and the clock would not restart until the next snap if even if the clock had been running prior to the previous snap).


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, vBulletin Solutions Inc.