View Single Post
Old 09-27-2004, 05:55 PM   #11
Grizzled Veteran
BaseballFan1's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: East Haven, CT
Posts: 110
BaseballFan1 is on a distinguished road

You really can't compare them.

Seattle Mariners stats for 2001

St. Louis Cards stats for 2004

Who is better (positional wise)?

C- Dan Wilson or Mike Matheny (Mike Matheny, good defensive catcher and can call a good game)
1B- John Olerud or Albert Pujols (Normally I would go with Olerud because he can still hit the ball but in this case I have to go with Pujols)
2B- Bret Boone or Tony Womack (Toss-up because Boone can be a good bat but he is okay defensively and Womack may not have power but he his a good #1 or #2 hitter)
SS- Carlos Gullien or Edgar Renteria (Edgar Renteria)
3B- David Bell or Scott Rolen (Scott Rolen)
RF- Ichiro or Larry Walker (Ichiro)
CF- Mike Cameron or Jim Edmonds (Jim Edmonds)
LF- Al Martin or Reggie Sanders (Reggie Sanders)

Starting Pitching-
Freddy Garcia or Matt Morris (Garcia)
Jamie Moyer or Woody Williams (Toss-up)
Aaron Sele or Chris Carpenter (Toss-up)
Paul Abbott or Jeff Suppan (Suppan because Abbott isn't that great of a pitcher)
John Halama/Joel Pineiro or Jason Marquis (Marquis because he has been clutch for this pitching staff this season)

The only thing that I've noticed that might be better.... The 2001 M's have a better bullpen than the Cards but Izzy is the better closer.
The Future of NASCAR: Kasey Kahne

"You can learn little from victory. You can learn everything from defeat."
-Christy Mathewson
BaseballFan1 is offline   Reply With Quote