Keep the 24-Team Playoff. Give Me Saturdays.

This past Saturday was, by miles, the best day of the college football season so far. And while the marquee game between Georgia and Alabama largely lived up to the billing and had major controversy to boot, that isn't why it was so good.

It was so good because of all the unexpected things that happened in conference games with both season-defining implications and bragging rights.

Oklahoma took down Texas and its struggling offense in a huge upset that was somehow fitting for the last 15 years of Red River Rivalry history. Florida's honeymoon period under Jon Sumrall officially crashed back down to reality by getting dominated by South Carolina.

UCLA's honeymoon with Bob Chesney kept going in a turnover fest at Oregon. LSU's run game got stuck in mud at Kentucky to give Lane Kiffin a second SEC loss before the Tigers' November showdowns against Alabama and Texas. Indiana had to hit two big fourth-quarter plays to get away with a road win at Nebraska before Ohio State comes to town next week. In Group of 6 land, FBS newbie North Dakota State finally met defeat against UNLV in a minor upset.

To me, days like Saturday are at the heart of what makes college football a unique and entertaining product. I'd trade all the extra playoff games in the world to make sure we never lose the fun of "normal" Saturdays like this one.

Of course, I don't get a choice in the matter. Every indication is that this will be the last year of a 12-team playoff, and 24 teams are on the docket for 2027.

Don't like preseason poll groupthink and the feedback loop it produces in the superconference era? Oh well, the powers that be think you'll watch anyway. Don't think it's very relevant to have playoff odds and projections as early as Labor Day? You'll probably have to make an even bigger effort to avoid that kind of content.

Since before a College Football Playoff existed, there have been worries about how a championship tournament would devalue the regular season. But the four-team playoff was too exclusive and was capped off with the final insult of an undefeated Power 4 conference champion missing out in 2023.

I didn't love the 12-team playoff when it was announced, but I also didn't expect that 10-2 or better would become a de facto requirement to participate. 10-win teams in power conferences, even in the era of highly unbalanced conference schedules, are good teams.

So perhaps there's a chance I'm pleasantly surprised when the playoff committee's top-25 rankings effectively become weekly Joe Lunardi updates for football. But I think this is finally the point where I finally say, "bigger is actually worse here and this change will affect my enjoyment of the larger product."

Even though Texas was No. 1 heading into the game against OU, it's not a given that the Longhorns will compete in the 12-team playoff this season. Even assuming games against Florida, Arkansas, and Texas A&M will be wins, Texas would need to go 3-1 against Ole Miss, Mississippi State, LSU, and Missouri to avoid a potentially disastrous 9-3 season.

With a 24-team bracket, Texas would be much more secure at this point. Games against Oklahoma always matter for the rivalry, but any 9-3 SEC team is probably getting in with a 24-team playoff.

Defenders of a larger playoff often point to the fact that the FCS conducts a 24-team playoff, but that's a format with automatic bids for all the conferences that want them. It's a true national tournament.

If the FBS wanted to conduct a playoff where the American champion, Pac-12 champion, and Conference USA champion all got access, I would love that. But we all know that has no chance of happening. Instead, the 24-team playoff will be chock full of SEC and Big Ten teams with a smattering of Big 12 and ACC teams participating and a token G6 representative.

And as we've already seen with Alabama and Oklahoma last season, the first round or two of a playoff dominated by the two richest conferences will lead to inevitable rematches between flawed teams that already played in a conference schedule.

While Group of 6 schools are effectively playing a different sport in terms of resources and talent compared to the P4 in 2026, the gap between the P2 and the Big 12 and ACC is going to keep getting bigger if a majority of the playoff belongs to two conferences.

That may have still happened with a 12-team playoff, but we'll see it accelerate when the extra playoff money funnels up to the Big Ten and SEC — and that's regardless of the Protect College Sports Act becoming law in something close to its current incarnation.

The next round of realignment is probably going to be a mad dash to get easier access to that 24-team playoff by becoming a Big Ten or SEC member. To me, this is going to be the worst part of my personal fandom of college football.

As I've mentioned before, since moving to North Carolina in 2021, I've followed the ACC closer than any other conferences. Even with its "All-Coast Conference" expansion, it has the Power 4 schools closest to me, so I follow it.

And in the superconference era, I've landed on a most uncomfortable truth: it's only a matter of time before Duke, North Carolina, Wake Forest, and NC State are split up. I don't know how exactly this will play out, but I know that Duke and UNC are much more desirable brands for the Big Ten or SEC to pursue than the other two. If there's somewhere around 6-10 spots left at the combined P2 table with no one getting kicked out, two of those will go to Duke and North Carolina.

Other regional fans have undoubtedly dealt with this feeling when say, Cal and Stanford split up from USC and UCLA or Oklahoma left Oklahoma State in the Big 12. But a college football with Saturdays that feel less important, a de facto NFC/AFC P2 setup, and a 24-team playoff is probably a sport I won't be as passionate about.

The SEC and Big Ten are banking that fans like me who are lifelong fans and follow season-long narratives today will stay that way when an inflated playoff begins. But fan relationships to sports aren't set in stone.

For example, I used to watch all the NFL I could on Thursdays, Sundays, and Mondays. Now, I really only focus on the Sunday afternoon windows in the weeks before Thanksgiving. If I'm particularly interested in a primetime game in the first couple months of the season, I'll get my sleep and wake up with an extended YouTube highlight available.

With as many as six game windows in a given week, there's too much product being presented for me to watch three days a week for four-plus months and playoffs. If college football goes down its inevitable path of playoff expansion, I'm probably not fully engaging until the last couple weeks of October.

Leave a Comment